J’s reply arrived last. The username was laconic, the reply brief: “Yep. Verified. Where’s the desk?” He lived in a building with iron fire escapes and an apartment that smelled faintly of coffee and old books. J was a carpenter by trade, which made it doubly strange that the desk—the very desk Alina had bought—had belonged to him once.

They all remembered the pop-up: an abandoned storefront turned into an ad-hoc stage for five hours. People danced barefoot on sawdust and there had been a cat with a collar spelled in glitter. They remembered that the four of them had stood in a doorway and watched a small, wild crowd form, feeling like pioneers staking claim to an otherwise indifferent city.

First she searched the faint clues in the picture. Micky’s haircut—an unmistakable crescent bowl—would stand out. Nadine wore a silver ring in the shape of a wave. J’s grin had a dimple on the left. The handwriting on the back suggested the writer liked flourish; perhaps they had a careful, patient life.